Tiny flies and trophy brook trout at Brookhaven Lake

Big Lake Nipigon brook trout hit flies down deep. Photo: Howard Meyerson

Big Lake Nipigon brook trout hit flies down deep. Photo: Howard Meyerson

By Howard Meyerson

FARWELL, MI — The lure of big brook trout always hooks me. It’s rare I turn down an opportunity to fish them. So, when Jeff Johnson called and invited me to fish at Brookhaven Lake, his private two-acre pond stocked with Canadian Lake Nipigon brook trout, I gladly said ‘yes.’

Brook trout are delightful fish, colorful and often aggressive. I’ve caught them on crawlers, spinners and flies; diminutive and colorful but picky beaver pond brookies, and those that hit like lightning on Upper Peninsula streams.

I looked forward to the day ahead and hoped to redeem myself after getting skunked two years ago. That’s when I first visited Johnson’s property to learn about his project.

Johnson and his son, Michael, acquired Brookhaven Lake in 2010 as means of honoring Johnson’s deceased father, George Johnson, who had left them an inheritance and had long lamented the disappearance of the grayling in Michigan. The once prized stream fish, with its sail-like dorsal fin, disappeared following the ravages of the early 20th century lumber boom, which destroyed much of its habitat. Overfishing also contributed to its demise along with competition from later-introduced European brown trout.


One of the smaller brookies caught this day. Photo: Howard Meyerson

The Johnsons honor his memory by stocking the pond with grayling each year. They also stocked it with 1,500 brook trout that have since grown and reproduced.

Youth groups, like Boy Scouts and school clubs, can arrange to fish for free and walk the self-guided nature trail on the property where they learn about Michigan’s trout fishing history and conservation.

“Be sure to let it sink. Count to 10, then strip strip strip,” Johnson instructed once we were out fishing from his driftboat. I began with a weighted, leech imitation. Our plan was to fish deep. The bottom was down 20 feet. But the lake surface was occasionally broken by the rise-forms of big, feeding brook trout.

Leeches, it turned out, wasn’t on the menu.

“Try this,” Johnson offered, 30 minutes later. “Trust me. This is the ticket.”

I looked with disbelief at the tiny, size 22 nymph he handed me. “And let’s add some fluorocarbon tippet, some one pound test,” he added. “When in doubt, go smaller.”

No wiser words have been uttered. A chunky, 14-inch brookie hit the tiny fly on my second cast and bent the rod, its full-coloration obvious below the surface. I played it for a few minutes and Johnson got the net.

“Not a bad fish for the first of the season,” Johnson said smiling.

Jeff Johnson rows around Brookhaven Lake on an early spring outing looking for brookies and grayling. Photo: Howard Meyerson

Jeff Johnson rows around Brookhaven Lake on an early spring outing looking for brookies and grayling. Photo: Howard Meyerson

It was the first of four beautiful brook trout we would land over the next couple of hours, fat and healthy, marvelously colored – perfect on a mild, sunny day just before the season

trout opener. Johnson landed two in the 15- and 16-inch range. One, much larger, broke off after a scuffle. That’s the nature of one pound test line.

“These small nymphs consistently catch fish,” Johnson affirmed after the second brookie hit the net. “If you are not catching any, go smaller.”

Johnson has introduced more than 500 youth to trout fishing at Brookhaven Lake. He will be adding a tepee to the grounds this year. His project is funded partially out-of- pocket. The rest, he attempts to recoup by charging anglers to fish there and have him guide. Fishing is flies-only and allowed only five or six days a month. All of the fish must be released.

“The biggest brook trout caught so far is 24 inches,” Johnson noted. “And the biggest grayling was 14 inches. The issue we’ve faced is the fish become educated. What started with 30- and 40-fish days became 30-fish days and then 15- to 20-fish days. But it is a good place for someone to bring their grandkid or their wife. On rivers you have worry about your back cast. Here, you don’t.”

Casting to a boil of fish on the surface, Johnson hooked and landed the first of two

This young grayling rose to a fly. Photo: Howard Meyerson

This young grayling rose to a fly. Photo: Howard Meyerson

grayling– 6-inch fish stocked last October. They survived the winter. He was ecstatic.

Twenty minutes later I had another fish on – again a brookie, but much larger this time. “Look at its back. That’s a big fish,” Johnson chortled as I fought it. In the net, we realize it is nearly 18 inches.

“That’s a great fish – at least two pounds,” Johnson offered excitedly. I nodded absently repeating ‘at least two pounds and 18 inches,’ still marveling at tiny fly it chose to eat.

“Now we have four brookies and two grayling,” Johnson said satisfied.

And, I was too. The sun was getting low.


This column appears on MLive Outdoors.

About Howard Meyerson

After more than 30 years in the outdoor writing business, you would think I'd know better.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Tiny flies and trophy brook trout at Brookhaven Lake

  1. mammaflybox says:

    Love it when people make an effort to get youth involved in fishing!


  2. Dave Franklin says:

    Hi Howard,

    Two weeks ago I landed and released a large rainbow trout I caught in the Huron River just below Argo dam. This trout as about 20 inches long and in the 4 – 5 lb class. I was astounded to know that a fish with very high water quality requirements was in the lower Huron. I would appreciate hearing whether or not other sport anglers have had a similar experience catching rainbow trout in the lower Huron.
    Kind Regards,
    Dave Franklin


    • Dave: You gotta show me where you got it ;-). I haven’t heard that before about the Huron though I know the local TU chapter is stocking some part of the river with trout,


      • Dave Franklin says:

        Hi Howard,
        It was just to the left of the Argo Dam on the down river side. There are a pile of large rocks next to the left side of the dam and I was standing on the rock closest to the left gate. I was using a small Mimmic Minnow, letting it drift just off the bottom in very strong current, using an Ultra-lite Ugly stick with 8lb test line.

        Tragically, there were no witnesses to see me catch the fish and, as I was on the rocks, there was no where to set the trout down to get a picture with my flip phone.

        As you may know, trout do no do well out of water for very long. I felt it was in the best interest to release it as soon as I got the hook out of its lower jaw.

        At 67, I have no reason not to tell the truth here. I have fished from the banks in the Argo pond area for four years and have caught and released hundreds of fish: rock bass, pike, and a very large number of small mouth.

        In fact, at the upper end of Argo where the twin expressway overpasses are, just before the big, heavy rain a week ago Wednesday, on the South side in the shallow, rocky area, I landed the largest small mouth bass of my life. I conservatively estimate it to have been 5+ pounds. I was so happy to release it back to the river. That small mouth bass and the Rainbow Trout were thrills of my life!

        Last year about this time, I caught and safely released in the Cascades over 150 6″ to 12 – 14″ small mouth bass in a couple of days. So far they are few and far between there.

        Hope I have answered your kind reply.

        Dave Franklin


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s